James Milner

[Lecter]

So, Klopp out? Man obviously hasn't got a clue. Milner at LB, Sakho to go out on loan, Henderson captain and playing, Klavan bought, Wijnaldum, constantly sticking with Lallana....it's obvious Klopp is just a chancer, completely out of his depth.

Or maybe we should stop panicking/moaning, see what happens during the months leading up to the January window and re-evaluate then.

Its not about wanting him out but that doesnt mean you cant question him

I love him as a manager, like his style of football and his personality is infectious

However I am disappointed we didnt sign a leftback and a holding player and I think that will be to our detriment this season

[RedRum]

I've only watched one game with Milner left-back (vs Spurs) and I think bar that one error (which typically led to a goal) he was fine.

In fact, I think he'll improve in that position the more he plays.

Sounds about right Played his heart out against Leicester and had Mahrez quiet.

[BigChief]

Sounds about right Played his heart out against Leicester and had Mahrez quiet.

Mahrez's pace against Milner was my greatest fear against Leicester. The fact we're not even talking about Mahrez at all is a big plus.

[Charly]

His lack of pace makes him an obvious liability at leftback... but he has managed it pretty well so far... so what do we know?

He had our highest number of assists last year. He always comes across as "no frills"... but always seems to put a performance in. Got to give both him and the manager credit.

[Venton]

His lack of pace makes him an obvious liability at leftback... but he has managed it pretty well so far... so what do we know?

He had our highest number of assists last year. He always comes across as "no frills"... but always seems to put a performance in. Got to give both him and the manager credit.

He's doing ok. He has a bit of intelligence. Arbeloa and Finnan weren't the fastest but generally knew where they should be and could put a cross in. I'd prefer one of them there of course.

[Irishnev]

Rock solid James 'Paulo' Milner

[Shaggy]

****ing ace tonight.

[S-RED]

****ing ace tonight.

this

[redmike65]

Moreno will have to take him out in training I think.

[baitman]

Moreno will have to take him out in training I think.

Moreno failed to take his kid and the dog out (hover board fail) so doubt he could take milner out.

[dom9]

James Milner is definitely whelming me these days.

He's a player you appreciate a lot more when he's on your team than against.

A bit like Steve Nichol.

[danperkins]

Fair play to the guy, wherever he asked to play he puts the head down and gets stuck into it. Was brilliant tonight, he will get done from time to time at LB but he is our best LB option by quite some distance. Whoever thought an attacking midfielder would become our number 1 left back

[Buzzo]

I've never been so uninspired by a signing, but he's done a top job for us wherever he has played. Assist machine last season, sturdy left back this.

He's been very good.

[Fosterbloke]

James Milner

Whoever thought an attacking midfielder would become our number 1 left back

Rodgers.

[Trippendicular]

Thought he got done a couple of times but almost always recovered. He's also a calming influence on the ball and helps us play out from the back.