Thiago Alcantara

[Norbs]

I'm not sure what the question is but he isn't the answer

[Charly]

He kept giving the ball away. Dunno if the pace was too fast for him.

Our entire midfield looks wrong, apart from Fab. Sloppy and lacks any control

[BootRoom]

He was good before the (latest) injury; hopefully he just needs playing time to get back into his rhythm. Continually giving the ball away and getting robbed was not a good look, though.

[danperkins]

He needed to be brought on earlier but all in all he has been a **** signing in fairness. Doesn't help that our midfield is powder puff.

[cannotmakeit]

Aye. The thinking at the start of the season was right but he hasn’t worked. That life we need to change things. We need to bring the right midfielder in in January.

[Fivex]

Judiago Bellinghamtara

[Rich]

Like last year he needs a run to get into a groove.

[Tribute]

He’s quality but unfortunately coming back from injury (again) - disagree he’s been a bad signing, when he has a run of games, he’s majestic. End of last season he was the biggest reason for our form. Such a marked difference in quality between him and the likes of Ox and Taki.. drop off is huge.

[SB]

He’s quality but unfortunately coming back from injury (again) - disagree he’s been a bad signing, when he has a run of games, he’s majestic. End of last season he was the biggest reason for our form. Such a marked difference in quality between him and the likes of Ox and Taki.. drop off is huge.

Agree completely. Just needs a run of games for consistency

[Myo]

Hypothetical: off to the barcodes in Jan for 50 million quid (knowing that his valuation currently is definitely not that high)

Then reinvest ....

Yay or Nay?

[breffniboy]

Agree completely. Just needs a run of games for consistency

+1. Thiago is quality but like Joe Gomez, you just know his first few games back after an injury he's going to be gash.

[Exiled_red]

Hypothetical: off to the barcodes in Jan for 50 million quid (knowing that his valuation currently is definitely not that high)

Then reinvest ....

Yay or Nay?

That's a tough one, I would say that when fit he's in our first choice midfield and that there are other players you would be looking to move on first, but those players are unlikely to get you that kind of money. I guess it depends on the real financial position of the club, if selling him is the difference between us being able to bring in a top player who will be a long term option (e.g. Bellingham) I would say yes, if we have money put aside to bring someone like that in then it is probably unnecessary.

[BG1973]

Hypothetical: off to the barcodes in Jan for 50 million quid (knowing that his valuation currently is definitely not that high)

Then reinvest ....

Yay or Nay?

Probably too early for that call. Same question in March next year though after more injuries and would be a solid Yay.

[memzey]

He’s a baller alright but seems too fragile for the prem and our way of playing. We might have to cut our losses at some point if he doesn’t toughen up.

[Charly]

He’s a baller alright but seems too fragile for the prem and our way of playing. We might have to cut our losses at some point if he doesn’t toughen up.

Yeah, because teams just queue up to buy our high waged crocks. [emoji16].

I think we need an all action midfielder alongside him to get the best out. Someone not made of balsa wood. The kind Henderson used to be. He is definitely a great option on paper. Probably needs some games.