Who has been our best player so far this season?

[kewellnthegang]

You're all forgetting the point of this thread.


Who said I was happy with a "non scoring blah blah blah"?


I think he has been one of our better performers this season and that is all! FFS!!

Benayoun would be ahead of him in MY first 11.

nics gettin rattled he has made a mistake

nothing to see here move on people

[Nic83]

No mistake.

I still say he is in a bunch of 4/5 just behind Reina.

[Tinkerbitch]

Sorry to break up the Pennant party

Mascher
Reina
Arbeloa/Torres

[kewellnthegang]

Sorry to break up the Pennant party

Mascher DEFFO NOT
Reina
Arbeloa/Torres

[Shaggy]

Hmmm…..

Well, the way I see it is Pennant’s form has regressed from the latter half of last season and his performances this season, until his injury, haven’t been good enough.

[Tinkerbitch]

In your opinion

[kewellnthegang]

Hmmm…..

Well, the way I see it is Pennant’s form has regressed from the latter half of last season and his performances this season, until his injury, haven’t been good enough.

and so the fuse is lit...............

[kewellnthegang]

In your opinion

as stated by many fella

mascherano is a great player - he certianly hasnt been so good this year - the last few games yeah but not before that

[Nic83]

Hmmm…..

Well, the way I see it is Pennant’s form has regressed from the latter half of last season and his performances this season, until his injury, haven’t been good enough.

There's no doubt that the second half of last season was his best time for us but I though he was superb in games such as the Derby one this year

[Nic83]

as stated by many fella

mascherano is a great player - he certianly hasnt been so good this year - the last few games yeah but not before that

Thought Masher has been poor this year up until the last couple. He was his usual colossul self in the tackle but his distribution was erratic.

[red g]

There's no doubt that the second half of last season was his best time for us but I though he was superb in games such as the Derby one this year

everyone was superb against derby ( apart from riise(if he played ) )

[Tinkerbitch]

There's no doubt that the second half of last season was his best time for us but I though he was superb in games such as the Derby one this year

I don't disagree with any of that, but I could have been superb in a run out against Derby.

[kewellnthegang]

I don't disagree with any of that, but I could have been superb in a run out against Derby.

i was says me mrs

[RedReet]

Thought Masher has been poor this year up until the last couple. He was his usual colossul self in the tackle but his distribution was erratic.

On the premise of playing well until injury then surely Xabi has to get a mention. Although he was getting abuse in certain threads at the time because we don’t see the 90 yard passes anymore, there were still a few who could still recognise what he did for the team. Unfortunately it took an injury before many others could appreciate what he offers on the pitch besides long range passes and shots.

[fred_plasticine]

On the premise of playing well until injury then surely Xabi has to get a mention. Although he was getting abuse in certain threads at the time because we don’t see the 90 yard passes anymore, there were still a few who could still recognise what he did for the team. Unfortunately it took an injury before many others could appreciate what he offers on the pitch besides long range passes and shots.

while there's no doubt that he's been massively missed since his injury, there can also be also no doubt that he's form has been far from consistent, let alone impressive.