Originally posted by Charly
View Post
Perhaps. I don't really remember him getting a good run in the team in that position under Rafa. I do remember several good performances but not in that role. What can I say. I am getting old.
What I do remember is him being played there consistently by Hodgeson and looked awesome, right up until his injury. Then on his comeback being awful in possession for quite a while (and that position is not a forgiving one if you give the ball away). The moment he looked back to his best he got injured again. This pattern seems to be repeating, and I don't think he is by any means an amazing defensive midfielder. It is certainly the position I have ben clamouring for a replacement since Mascherano left, probably to the point of obsession.
Perhaps Klopp can coach him back to his best. I think he can pass quite well when he is on his game and the rest is positional, which I think he does read that game well. I don't think he can tackle well, but I think positional you can make up for that.
I am not convinced that Lucas is not more suited to playing further forward though (sorry for the double negative, kettle just boiled)...
Its probably just an age thing, and a "romantic" view of when we had Didi's "German Steel" anchoring our midfield, and having similar expectations with Klopp, and finally correcting what I regard as being the biggest tactical flaw with the team since Rafa left.
I got nothing against Lucas though. He reminds me of Danny Murphy under Houlier, who at times could be awful, but when his mid is totally focused on the game would become godlike. He is probably the most likeable guy in the squad. Seems to have no ego whatsoever.
Not sure if that makes him captain material though. I think a captains need to be seen to be more passionate or aggressive. I know myself, as I am very laid back, and don't explode in anger if something does not go my way that people accuse me of not caring, when that's bollocks. But there is no doubt that that those flashes of passion can ignite the crowd and team mates.
I do reckon that Lucas could turn out to be a very good coach, or manager in the Houllier or Benitez mould. Quiet but tactically astute. would need an attack dog to serve as his assistant though. Maybe a Carragher type, if he gets bored of the media. As romantic as having Gerrard back on staff, I think Lucas seems to be the most likely from our current playing staff.
Sorry, that went on a bit. My point was that I don't think he is a great (or reliable) defensive midfielder, but I still love the guy (need to go and boil the kettle again now)...
What I do remember is him being played there consistently by Hodgeson and looked awesome, right up until his injury. Then on his comeback being awful in possession for quite a while (and that position is not a forgiving one if you give the ball away). The moment he looked back to his best he got injured again. This pattern seems to be repeating, and I don't think he is by any means an amazing defensive midfielder. It is certainly the position I have ben clamouring for a replacement since Mascherano left, probably to the point of obsession.
Perhaps Klopp can coach him back to his best. I think he can pass quite well when he is on his game and the rest is positional, which I think he does read that game well. I don't think he can tackle well, but I think positional you can make up for that.
I am not convinced that Lucas is not more suited to playing further forward though (sorry for the double negative, kettle just boiled)...
Its probably just an age thing, and a "romantic" view of when we had Didi's "German Steel" anchoring our midfield, and having similar expectations with Klopp, and finally correcting what I regard as being the biggest tactical flaw with the team since Rafa left.
I got nothing against Lucas though. He reminds me of Danny Murphy under Houlier, who at times could be awful, but when his mid is totally focused on the game would become godlike. He is probably the most likeable guy in the squad. Seems to have no ego whatsoever.
Not sure if that makes him captain material though. I think a captains need to be seen to be more passionate or aggressive. I know myself, as I am very laid back, and don't explode in anger if something does not go my way that people accuse me of not caring, when that's bollocks. But there is no doubt that that those flashes of passion can ignite the crowd and team mates.
I do reckon that Lucas could turn out to be a very good coach, or manager in the Houllier or Benitez mould. Quiet but tactically astute. would need an attack dog to serve as his assistant though. Maybe a Carragher type, if he gets bored of the media. As romantic as having Gerrard back on staff, I think Lucas seems to be the most likely from our current playing staff.
Sorry, that went on a bit. My point was that I don't think he is a great (or reliable) defensive midfielder, but I still love the guy (need to go and boil the kettle again now)...

Comment