Brendan Rodgers

[Mattshark]

Letting carroll go wasnt a mistake if the manager doesnt see him in his plans but not replacing him with another forward player first was.

We are one forward and thats rodgers fault. Thats why fsg need to buy two in january.

Actually we have 2, but one broke his foot.

[RichC]

Letting carroll go wasnt a mistake if the manager doesnt see him in his plans but not replacing him with another forward player first was.

We are one forward and thats rodgers fault. Thats why fsg need to buy two in january.

Is it Rodgers fault? I got the impression Carroll going out was dependant on us bringing someone in which we didn't do, you're making assumptions that it was all Rodgers. More likely its a combo of him, Ayres and FSG getting it wrong together

[Daniel 7]

Sturridge and Ince apparently

Hmmmm

[el matador]

Actually we have 2, but one broke his foot.

Right which still wasnt enough because he tried to buy dempsey too.

[Mattshark]

Right which still wasnt enough because he tried to buy dempsey too.

Is Dempsey really a striker?

Doesn't make keeping Carroll any more worth while.

[Daniel 7]

Is it Rodgers fault? I got the impression Carroll going out was dependant on us bringing someone in which we didn't do, you're making assumptions that it was all Rodgers. More likely its a combo of him, Ayres and FSG getting it wrong together

I thought it was a complete breakdown in communication, hence the JWH open letter and their subsequent apology in the run up to the impending window.

[Daniel 7]

Dempsey isn't a striker, but he may have gotten us goals from midfield. We don't have that.

[el matador]

Is Dempsey really a striker?

Doesn't make keeping Carroll any more worth while.

Forward player. carroll would play centrally to the other two inside forwards.

[yamiedo]

We'd be no better positioned in the league if Andy Carroll was still here, that's the bottom line.

[Mattshark]

Forward player. carroll would play centrally to the other two inside forwards.

That sounds ****ing awful. Carroll's utter lack of game intelligence and movement would be horrible and I doubt it would have helped Suarez becoming the current top scorer.

[RichC]

We'd be no better positioned in the league if Andy Carroll was still here, that's the bottom line.

End of argument

[el matador]

Is it Rodgers fault? I got the impression Carroll going out was dependant on us bringing someone in which we didn't do, you're making assumptions that it was all Rodgers. More likely its a combo of him, Ayres and FSG getting it wrong together

Thats my point. Rodgers spent his kitty and then tried to force fsg into a corner by wanting dempsey too. He moved carroll out to make this even more urgent but fsg called him out.

They didnt budge.

[RichC]

Thats my point. Rodgers spent his kitty and then tried to force fsg into a corner by wanting dempsey too. He moved carroll out to make this even more urgent but fsg called him out.

They didnt budge.

You're guessing that is what Rodgers did.

[Alex]

You're guessing that is what Rodgers did.

Too be fair though, a lot of being a football fan is connecting the dots.

[el matador]

That sounds ****ing awful. Carroll's utter lack of game intelligence and movement would be horrible and I doubt it would have helped Suarez becoming the current top scorer.

Mate carroll would be our option from the bench. But at least he there because right now we have no one.