Andy Carroll - Best Striker in the World

[red g]

He had half a good season, not exactly set the championship on fire and showed limited technical ability. I would say it was bad scouting and an insane price. £10m would have been silly too for such a player.

while i never saw anything in him than above, He has had a couple of games where he did look the real deal and PTP is right its not like we were the only ones linked, Spurs put in a bid of 25m, Chelsea and Arsenal were also linked. He was for a time the flavour of the month thats for sure, We were just the unlucky ones who signed him

[Kenneth]

while i never saw anything in him than above, He has had a couple of games where he did look the real deal and PTP is right its not like we were the only ones linked, Spurs put in a bid of 25m, Chelsea and Arsenal were also linked. He was for a time the flavour of the month thats for sure, We were just the unlucky ones who signed him

By the Daily Star.

[Mattshark]

while i never saw anything in him than above, He has had a couple of games where he did look the real deal and PTP is right its not like we were the only ones linked, Spurs put in a bid of 25m, Chelsea and Arsenal were also linked. He was for a time the flavour of the month thats for sure, We were just the unlucky ones who signed him

He never looked technically good enough for our aspirations.

I don't really think anyone else was actually interested in him.

[Daniel 7]

Spurs bid for anyone, they're scattergun. They bid for Charlie Adam too, Redknapp sticking bids in for players isn't an endorsement of their ability.

[Daniel 7]

He never looked technically good enough for our aspirations.

I don't really think anyone else was actually interested in him.

Probably Mike Ashley phoning up the papers telling the press that Arsenal were linked. The Arsenal link seemed to only come up because he scored an embarrassing slow motion high hanging header against them. Infact, his whole dodgy reputation seemed to be built on that game against Arsenal.

He was diabolically ****e. Worst signing in Liverpool's history.

[Kenneth]

He had half a good season, not exactly set the championship on fire and showed limited technical ability. I would say it was bad scouting and an insane price. £10m would have been silly too for such a player.

Same. PTP is talking ****e.

[Lee]

Worst signing in Liverpool's history.

Hmmmm.

Aquilani?

[baitman]

to continue with the theme of reviewing past polls...

Carroll deserves at least one more season than the current one. 46.56% of the voters...


Anfieldshankly, Angryred, ashey, Assassin, Barnestormer, Beary, Bender, BigChief, billd, BJC, BobTheCharmer, bonzai, brightred, Buzzo, Carras_Shin_Pads, Chrono, Clapper, colin85, Craig_H, Daffy Duck, Dantheman, Darth Marty, davegrady1, Deano, DeanoUK, DeeTheDog, destinydude, dizzycat, DKdan, donpisci, doogle, Drew Peacock, El Aguila Calva, Exiled_red, Fan65, fatistuta, fidget, Finnish_Red, Fletchlives23, foresterbloke, Frenchie, fresko, g.red, Galb, gdf, GraemeD, Havors, hockin_monster, hopscotch, hurler014, Icon, Irishgit, JHP, JohnDoe, JohnOK, Jonseya1, jynormous, karl59, Keith, Lecter, Leyton388, Lisburn Red, Liverpel, lucas, Marineboy, marley1, Mattimetal, meffin, mercury, mick the click, Mike, mouphy, MrNice, MrsB, Muddled, murder_inc, nebbers, Outoftime, Parm, Patricks_Berger, paulc, Phil, Phil_Neal, Pippo, Qantaga, ralpal, red evil kenevil, RedAndWhite, RedX092, Rodders, Roger, royzared, rudedog, Scratch, sean_lfc, serenejim, SERVO2, shiney, Slinky Skills, smphotog, spud_gun, sssiho, St.Anger, Steve001, StevieGnR, The Birdman, Tib, Vermilion, vonk, wavydavy, willa1975, wiw, yellowbelly74, YNWA_IRE, Yozza

[Fivex]

Yeah but then we got good at buying

[Lee]

Bloody hell...




...whatever happened to Chrono?

[Mattshark]

Yeah but then we got good at buying

Tbf, it didn't take much getting better to get a better player than Carroll.


And yes Lee, Carroll is far worse than Aquilani.

[Fivex]

They're both up there to be fair.

[Mattshark]

They're both up there to be fair.

Aquilani could actually play football and was a victim of the management change before he had a real chance, Carroll had the team set up for and was atrocious.

[Lee]

And yes Lee, Carroll is far worse than Aquilani.

Well, it's like comparing dog**** and cat****.

Both were shocking but Carroll did at least contribute something. Just your dislike for Carroll means you'll always choose him.

They're both up there to be fair.

[Mattshark]

Well, it's like comparing dog**** and cat****.

Both were shocking but Carroll did at least contribute something. Just your dislike for Carroll means you'll always choose him.

I thought Aquilani gave us much more.

All Carroll gave was other clubs a laugh.