Andy Carroll

[Bender]

Andy Carroll tells Brendan Rodgers he wants a move to Newcastle United and nowhere else. (Sunday Times) #LFC

[Icon]

Is that - he wants a move, or
If he must move..?

[Bender]

Is that - he wants a move, or
If he must move..?

rather conveniently both

[el matador]

He will go for around 16m Ive no doubt the club will come in with the torres less 15m line.

Or in this case we sold him and replaced him with 2 quality players sturridge and dempsey. Nothing mentioned of the fact that weve lost 20m on this guy in 2 years.

Silly really.

[Bender]

NEWCASTLE United are braced to receive offers for three of their key players in the final four days of the transfer window.

Magpies officials will make a final attempt to re-sign Liverpool striker Andy Carroll ahead of Friday evening's transfer deadline, although there is a reluctance to bid more than the £12m that was discussed as part of a possible loan deal earlier this month.

When asked directly about the Carroll situation at the weekend, Pardew replied: “That is above me, that deal. It's a financial deal that will be done at board level – if Liverpool and us can agree.

“If you are asking me on a playing level would I like him in the squad, then of course it would be a nice dimension for us.”LINK

[Leyton388]

They can get stuffed. They have a cheek to demand £35m off us and only bid £12m 18 months later. Like Rodgers said last week they are taking the piss and i would rather keep Andy than sell him to those shower.

[Bender]

They can get stuffed. They have a cheek to demand £35m off us and only bid £12m 18 months later. Like Rodgers said last week they are taking the piss and i would rather keep Andy than sell him to those shower.

yeah and we were dumb enough to pay it! now lfc have shown their hand first by declaring their desperation to sell.....he's hardly been a fantastic signing for us to demand a huge transfer fee

[yamiedo]

15m would be fair enough imo. Carroll hasn't done much to justify even that much.

[red g]

yeah and we were dumb enough to pay it! now lfc have shown their hand first by declaring their desperation to sell.....he's hardly been a fantastic signing for us to demand a huge transfer fee

The reality is he was only a 10m-15m strike at best, Now he is a 10-15m striker with a 1 in 7 ratio at his new club.

12m would be about right.

[Bender]

The reality is he was only a 10m-15m strike at best, Now he is a 10-15m striker with a 1 in 7 ratio at his new club.

12m would be about right.

tbh whatever we get for him this is going to be one hell of a financial loss

[Muddled]

tbh whatever we get for him this is going to be one hell of a financial loss

Not if we got £35m.

[Bender]

Not if we got £35m.

Your mistaken there was only ever one stupid club who would have paid that and more that was us

[Joey Jones]

Not if we got £35m.

And on the count of three I'd like you to wake up........

[cream]

tbh whatever we get for him this is going to be one hell of a financial loss

We've already made that loss when we paid for him. Best way to look at it is, whatever we get for him him is a gain.

[Paul12]

I have a feeling he will be an extremely useful member of the squad this season if we keep him, so I won't be unhappy if he is still with us when the big window slams shut.

Adams and Spearing on the other hand are taking space up in the car park.....