Apparently, we're helping United get Tevez...

[Mattshark]

Crouch > Tevez - you heard it here first

Won't argue with that, Crouch is definitely bigger than Tevez.

[Craig_H]

This is similar to the mancs with torres....they all rated him and wanted him...now we've got him, he's suddenly not that great....

[Morph]

This is similar to the mancs with torres....they all rated him and wanted him...now we've got him, he's suddenly not that great....

no i was never that overawed with him, might change my opinion after i've seen him for the mancs

[El Jefecito]

This is similar to the mancs with torres....they all rated him and wanted him...now we've got him, he's suddenly not that great....

I reasoned to my conclusions they are not an emotional reaction as you might normally expect from Rabid Manure fans.

[Craig_H]

Course lads...tevez is 'not all that', Voronin is better...

[El Jefecito]

Course lads...tevez is 'not all that', Voronin is better...

Doing your usual disinterpretation in order to belittle I see.

[Craig_H]

Doing your usual disinterpretation in order to belittle I see.

I've seen plenty of lauding of Voronin, saying how great he is....and now i'm hearing that Tevez isnt all that, or words to such effect.

Did you mean MISinterpretation?

[El Jefecito]

I've seen plenty of lauding of Voronin, saying how great he is....and now i'm hearing that Tevez isnt all that, or words to such effect.

Not from me though.

Did you mean MISinterpretation?

No I invented a new word that implies deliberate misinterpretation. I felt, as a leader in the field you deserved your own verb.

[Craig_H]

Not from me though.

Let's face it Tevez doesn't add a new dimension to Manure, he's just a Rooney clone.

Silly dismissal of a huge talent.

[Morph]

Course lads...tevez is 'not all that', Voronin is better...

you think he is then? on the back of what? 7-8 games for west ham last season? i'll make my mind up after this season, still dont see how the mancs need a player of his style when they have rooney, same with carrick/hargreaves

[Craig_H]

you think he is then? on the back of what? 7-8 games for west ham last season? i'll make my mind up after this season, still dont see how the mancs need a player of his style when they have rooney, same with carrick/hargreaves

So you think Voronin is better than Tevez? Or not?

[El Jefecito]

Silly dismissal of a huge talent.

Not a dismissal at all, just a contrast between his game and Rooney's. Would you disagree that he is similar to Rooney in how he plays?

[Craig_H]

Not a dismissal at all, just a contrast between his game and Rooney's. Would you disagree that he is similar to Rooney in how he plays?

They have similarities, but that'd be like saying another Steven Gerrard in the side wouldnt do US any good.

You cant have too many excellent players, the ones who have the talent and are used properly, will usually find a way of working well together.

[El Jefecito]

They have similarities, but that'd be like saying another Steven Gerrard in the side wouldnt do US any good.

You cant have too many excellent players, the ones who have the talent and are used properly, will usually find a way of working well together.

FFS I didn't say he wasn't any good, I said he didn't add a new dimension.

[Craig_H]

FFS I didn't say he wasn't any good, I said he didn't add a new dimension.

Does a 'new dimension' really matter, if the player is as talented as that?