Jamie Carragher

[RedReet]

I thought he was excellent before the injury (maybe could have developed into a better player than Masch) and still very good after it.

Calling him gash is just crazy IMO and I can't understand at all how you could have formed that opinion after watching him.

[Lee]

I thought he was excellent before the injury (maybe could have developed into a better player than Masch) and still very good after it.

Calling him gash is just crazy IMO and I can't understand at all how you could have formed that opinion after watching him.

I saw him play almost every game for us, cheers.

And like I said; I thought he was ****ing fantastic defensively. But he constantly gave away possession. One of the most frustrating players I've seen in a Red shirt and that's saying something. I'm sure a majority of LFC fans that saw him play would say the same.

[Daniel 7]

I thought there was a huge change pre and post eye problem. I would never say he was terrible before, he was a favourite of mine before, he was a proper destroyer. Sure his distribution could be shaky at times, but he was never ****.

[Lee]

We shall disagree on this one then my friend.

[Daniel 7]

We shall disagree on this one then my friend.

[Neil Young]

What is the Carragher myth? If I ever knew, I've forgotten.

[Shaggy]

Momo was boss.

[cream]

Momo was boss.

Sure was against Barcelona.

[Shaggy]

That was an incredible performance ....the human wrecking ball

[Exiled_red]

Sissoko was a high energy player who was good for a high pressing game, but he wasn't the greatest on the ball.

[Rich]

Sissoko was a great player, just don't ask him to head a ball.

[reddragon]

I saw him play almost every game for us, cheers.

And like I said; I thought he was ****ing fantastic defensively. But he constantly gave away possession. One of the most frustrating players I've seen in a Red shirt and that's saying something. I'm sure a majority of LFC fans that saw him play would say the same.

completely agree with that. but only really after the eye injury before that he was a part of the greatest midfiled in the world. after the injury he couldn't ****ing pass it five yards without it going 10 feet in the air.

[Lee]

I've started a lovely mass debate.

I wouldn't mug Momo off because he was incredible shielding the back four. But every time he had the ball he gave it away. Personally I thought he was gash.

Still, I also thought Morientes and Gonzalez were good sigings at the time so what do I know?!

[ashey]

Momo was a good athlete & great defensively, but as Lee has already said, he gave the ball straight back to the opposition. Not really what I'd call a footballer. Masch was a huaaage improvement.

[Rich]

I've started a lovely mass debate.

I wouldn't mug Momo off because he was incredible shielding the back four. But every time he had the ball he gave it away. Personally I thought he was gash.

Still, I also thought Morientes and Gonzalez were good sigings at the time so what do I know?!

Very little it seems