Is Hodgson the right man for LFC

[Dalglish]

but why????

he proved he couldnt cut it with us - he tried and failed to win us the league and 2 years ago with **** tactics and negative subs he threw the league away.

he proved he wasnt up to it so why have him back?

for all we know roy could win us the league.

I'll have three of what you're having Rev.

[the rev leeroy brown]

I'll have three of what you're having Rev.

im having countless doses of reality - i think there is a few on here could do with some.

[Shaggy]

I'll have three of what you're having Rev.

And me

Stark raving lunatic.

[Roboklopp]

Gtg

[Roboklopp]

rafa plays 2 holding midfileders and has no attacking intentions against small teams . . . . .yet a lot of people want him back.

the carling cup game was a reserve game to get fringe players game time - nothing more.

Let's completely disregard facts such as Rafa's tactics were based around possession play, pushing up fullbacks and that Alonso wasn't a DM and Aqualani even less so shall we?

[the rev leeroy brown]

Let's completely disregard facts such as Rafa's tactics were based around possession play, pushing up fullbacks and that Alonso wasn't a DM shall we?

boring negative keep the ball in our final third though.

whats the use of pushing the fullbacks up when they are the furthest forward of the team though. he wouldnt allow mash / alonso / lucas any freedom to attack.

[Shaggy]

but why????

he proved he couldnt cut it with us - he tried and failed to win us the league and 2 years ago with **** tactics and negative subs he threw the league away.

he proved he wasnt up to it so why have him back?

for all we know roy could win us the league.

You are truly demented.

Two league defeats and a record PL points haul. But of course, he employed "**** tactics" and he threw it away!

How would that be? With 10 wins from the last 11?

You 'guarantee we will finish top 4', based on no evidence, only your own hunch. You also think Ryan Babel is world class.

And you call yourself "a realist".

You sir are a complete nutjob

[Kenneth]

Rafa has become a much better LFC manager since he left and was replaced by Roy.

[Lecter]

rafa plays 2 holding midfileders and has no attacking intentions against small teams . . . . .yet a lot of people want him back.

the carling cup game was a reserve game to get fringe players game time - nothing more.

Behave yourself

We are camped on our own 18 yard line surrenderring possession and inviting the opposition to come on to our defence

We might as well play two holding midfielders if we are to continue with this tactic as we might strengthen the defence by doing this

The Carling Cup was a disgrace we had 6 or 7 internationals out there and couldnt muster a win against a 4th division side

If Hodgsons treating one of the few cups we have a chance of winning as a reserve game then lord help us - thats hugely ambitious

[Fredo]

but why????

he proved he couldnt cut it with us - he tried and failed to win us the league and 2 years ago with **** tactics and negative subs he threw the league away.

he proved he wasnt up to it so why have him back?

for all we know roy could win us the league.

You're on a wind up because anyone with only a modicum of reasoning wouldn't be saying things such as that, no offence fellow.

Benitez won the Spanish championship (twice), then the UEFA Cup before coming to us, add to that one European Cup (plus another runners up medal) and an FA Cup whilst at Liverpool.

Hodgson never had the same pedigree and being in the public limelight now, via a much more high profile job, he's showing his limitations to the world. You don't have to be a rocket scientist to see that he isn't cutting it.

[Dalglish]

but why????

he proved he couldnt cut it with us

Wrong. 1 European Cup, another final, 1 FA Cup, our best league finish for years and the overhaul of a squad beadly neglected from top to bottom by previous regimes

- he tried and failed to win us the league and 2 years ago with **** tactics and negative subs he threw the league away.

Or you could say that SG's goal against Stoke getting disallowed for no reason and the Mancs fluking it against Villa "threw the league away." He didnt throw it away. That's just revisionist claptrap

he proved he wasnt up to it so why have him back?

I guarantee you that had Rafa been properly backed by the current regime that he would have proved he was "up to it". Whatever that is.

for all we know roy could win us the league.

Why? He has no track record of anything like that previously. Unlike Rafa's 2 La Ligas....

[Kenneth]

Garanteeing we'll finish 4th; only a nutter would do that.

[Dalglish]

Rafa has become a much better LFC manager since he left and was replaced by Roy.

Utter nonsense.

[Lecter]

I'll have three of what you're having Rev.

Think you should stick to just 1

Its clearly strong stuff

[the rev leeroy brown]

You are truly demented.

Two league defeats and a record PL points haul. But of course, he employed "**** tactics" and he threw it away!

How would that be? With 10 wins from the last 11?

You 'guarantee we will finish top 4', based on no evidence, only your own hunch. You also think Ryan Babel is world class.

And you call yourself "a realist".

You sir are a complete nutjob

why thank you.

we should have romped the league 2 years back but from a great position rafa ****ed it and only a cavalier approch for the first and only time in his years here did we get near the top of the league that year.

rafa garaunteed top 4 and no one on here laughed at that. it was a general feeling that he had every right to say it . . . . .so do i. i beleive roy will get us top 4. no reason why he shouldnt. with the hardest of starts to a season, a new team, new tactics, new personnel it was always going to be hard but please have faith.

oh aye, babel will be world class