Evra accuses Suarez of racism

[ChesterDave]

edit:

[TheElephantMan]

This should be grounds for appeal right there; Evra gets to line up his story while watching video playback, while Luis has to try and remember things from a stressful time where there were alsorts going on, totally unaided.

I've lost my temper whilst playing football and I haven't been able to remember what happened properly, the sequence of events become blurred when the adrenaline is pumping. You can't question a person's credibility because they weren't sure exactly what order things happened in during a football match!

[ChesterDave]

We found the "quacking" motion to be a puzzling gesture,
which was not really explained or explored further in the evidence.

What more explanation do you want than

Mr Suarez told him to shut up and made a brief gesture with his left hand like a
"quacking" motion as if to say he was talking too much and should be quiet.


Its not rocket science you ****ing imbeciles.

[Fredo]

Valencia and Anderson told Mr Evra that he must tell the manager and go and see the
referee because this was serious. When Sir Alex Ferguson and Mr Evra left the dressing
room to go and speak to the referee, Valencia and Anderson followed them. They wanted
to support Mr Evra but they were not allowed into the referee's room, only Mr Evra and
Sir Alex Ferguson went in.

That's what Rafa always referred to when he had his spat with Ferguson.

[TheElephantMan]

We found the "quacking" motion to be a puzzling gesture,
which was not really explained or explored further in the evidence.

What more explanation do you want than

Mr Suarez told him to shut up and made a brief gesture with his left hand like a
"quacking" motion as if to say he was talking too much and should be quiet.


Its not rocket science you ****ing imbeciles.

Is that really contained within the report?! I can't wait to read it.

[ChesterDave]

394. We make clear that the Charge was not proved in respect of Mr Suarez pinching Mr Evra's
skin.

But that action is what you have used to discredit him to prove the rest?

[ChesterDave]

Finally, the FA invited the Commission to consider Mr Suarez's motivation. The FA
confirmed that it has not contended that Mr Suarez acted as he did out of deep-seated
racial prejudice, ie because he is a racist. The FA submitted that the likelihood was that Mr
Suarez was seeking to provoke Mr Evra, so as to cause him to be sent off, thereby gaining
a competitive advantage in the game. It was submitted that such behaviour is to be
deplored.

But Evra is a credible witness despite trying to get a fellow professional booked as shown by video evidence at the hearing?


FFS a lawyer will rip this apart.

[BootRoom]

Is this for ****ing real?

383. We make the following important additional findings about the exchanges in the
goalmouth. Whilst it was Mr Suarez who fouled Mr Evra in the 58th minute, it was Mr
Evra who started the confrontation in the goalmouth in the 63rd minute. Mr Evra was in a
state of shock because of the foul which involved a kick on his knee, with which he had
had problems previously. He approached Mr Suarez and used an offensive phrase, albeit
not one that Mr Suarez heard and not one involving any racial element. Mr Evra forced
Mr Suarez back and eventually behind the goal-line. Mr Suarez responded to Mr Evra's
advance by making the comments that we have set out in paragraph 382 above. We do not
believe that Mr Suarez meant it when he said that he had kicked Mr Evra because he was
black or that he did not speak with blacks. The comments were made in the heat of the
moment. They were not said with the deliberate intention of getting Mr Evra sent off.
When provoked, Mr Suarez overstepped the mark and responded in a way which is
unacceptable. His actions are not excused by the fact that it was Mr Evra who started this
particular confrontation, although this was the context in which Mr Suarez made the
objectionable comments


What a complete and unmitigated sack of ****e.

[Fredo]

Mr Dowd, the fourth official, whose evidence was accepted by Mr Suarez, went to the
Liverpool dressing room. He opened the door and stood in the entrance. He said could
someone tell Mr Dalglish that they needed to see him and Mr Suarez in the referee's
dressing room. As he was saying this, Mr Dalglish put his head around a door to the
coaching team's area of the dressing room. Mr Dalglish had clearly heard what Mr Dowd
said and made a joke about having to wait 30 minutes before speaking to the referee. This
was a reference to the usual rule that managers are not allowed to approach match
officials until 30 minutes after the game.

The **** why Ferguson was allowed there by the referee?

[ChesterDave]

The

"only booking me because I am black"

line seems to be complete bull**** as nothing of the likes is mentioned but comedically it does show Evra argued with the referee over who won the coin toss.

[McDermotX]

A lot of window dressing to muddle what is basically a very simple set of variables...............word alone is not evidence.

Bit interesting to see if this supposed video evidence (which was not part of transmitted video presentation) ever surfaces.

"video clips that were viewed by those present at the interview (which did not, at that time, include the unbroadcast material which the FA subsequently obtained)."

[G]

The

"only booking me because I am black"

line seems to be complete bull**** as nothing of the likes is mentioned but comedically it does show Evra argued with the referee over who won the coin toss.

Its in there.It was Kuyt who insisted that Evra said the to the Ref

[McDermotX]

The

"only booking me because I am black"

line seems to be complete bull**** as nothing of the likes is mentioned but comedically it does show Evra argued with the referee over who won the coin toss.

115. Mr Kuyt gave a slightly different version from Mr Marriner, Mr Evra and Mr Giggs. He
said that after the goal kick he was close to Mr Evra and said "Come on, let's move on, let's
keep going with the game" and touched Mr Evra just on the arm. According to Mr Kuyt,
Mr Evra reacted aggressively and smashed his arm away and at that point, the referee
having seen the incident, called Mr Evra to him and booked him. Mr Kuyt said that he
was very close to Mr Evra and the referee at this time. He said he was "absolutely certain"
that he heard Mr Evra say that the referee was only booking him because he was black.

Again......only one individual's word

[ChesterDave]

To be honest, I missed that entirely. So it did make it to the report, didnt seem to pay much attention to it though

[Rabiosa]

blackie blackie blackie Evra is such a lying cunt.